Geoff Tate – ‘Kings And Thieves’ Album Review

If Geoff Tate is rattled by the recent upheavals in his musical career, you’d be hard-pressed to tell from his latest solo album ‘Kings and thieves’ which is imbued with the singer’s customary self-possession and clarity of thought with no hint of the turmoil which has embroiled his life elsewhere. The first thing to note is that ‘Kings and thieves’ lends a great deal of credence to Geoff’s recent claims that he has been the sole creative force behind the Queensryche machine for some years and, indeed, it is arguable that separated from the pressure of his erstwhile colleagues and the band’s lofty name itself, Geoff has been able to indulge in a musical exercise which calmly and capably outstrips most of Queensryche’s recent output, whilst not deviating too heavily from the musical blueprint that the band have been utilising pretty much since ‘hear in the now frontier’

Fans of Tate will be entirely unsurprised to learn that the emphasis here is far removed from the power-metal histrionics of early Queensryche, the music sitting far closer to the mid-tempo rock of ‘Promised land’ or ‘hear in the now frontier’; but where speed has been sacrificed, there is instead a sense of power, melody, groove and feel, not dissimilar from Geoff’s debut solo effort, and whilst the band play with the confidence you’d expect from seasoned professionals, there is an edge to the proceedings that suggests a seriousness of purpose and mutual respect between the musicians that elevates this above the ego-polishing so often found in solo efforts. As much as Geoff allows his fellow musicians plenty of space in the spotlight, however, it would be surprising if it wasn’t his voice that proved to be the star of the show, and so it transpires with Geoff’s rich warm tones sitting comfortably at the heart of the mix. His voice may no longer be the air-siren of yore, but when he hits his stride, as he does frequently on this record; his voice still has the power to send shivers down the spine. The music, meanwhile, is eclectic, well-written and immaculately recorded, neatly drawing upon Geoff’s thirty-odd years of experience in the music industry without sounding faddy or contrived.

Geoff may not employ the full-on metal attack that many long-time Queensryche fans would undoubtedly like, but this largely subtle release has plenty to offer his followers over the course of its eleven tracks. Opening track ‘she slipped away’ sets the scene nicely, with Kelly Grey’s rippling guitars reminiscent of ‘Empire’-era Queensryche covering classic U2, and, having missed Kelly’s more bluesy interpretation of Queensryche tracks since he departed the band following ‘live evolution’, it’s good to hear the talented guitarist allowed the space to indulge in his art on many of the tracks here.  Aside from Kelly, Geoff has also employed fellow Seattle musician (and former Mother Love Bone member) Gregg Gilmore on drums, Chris Zukas on bass and long-time collaborator Randy Gane (with whom both Geoff and Kelly played in Myth) on keyboards. The band also features harmony vocals courtesy of Jason Ames and Emily Tate.

Having impressed with ‘she slipped away’, its warm, driving rock a perfect reminder of Geoff’s skill as a beguiling and intimate front man, the band kick into the chunky groove of ‘take a bullet’ with its funky bass line and keyboard stabs adding depth to Kelly’s heavy, grinding guitars. Geoff, meanwhile, sounds like he’s having a good deal of fun with the vocals, his voice, clear, powerful and enthused throughout. ‘In the dirt’ has a slinky riff that grooves and swirls in the dust, the feeling once again being that this would be the perfect soundtrack to an open-topped ride through the sand-strewn highways of America, the music evocative of grand landscapes and open spaces even as each track is a short, contemporary stab of melodic hard rock rather than the more lengthy, progressive jams of Geoff’s day job.

A great track with an immensely annoying title, ‘Say U luv it’ with its text-speak (and thus instantly aggravating) nomenclature is a slice of carefully constructed electronic-enhanced rock that comes off like a mix between alt-rock stalwarts Live and Nine inch Nails, whilst Geoff once again sounds like he’s enjoying the freedom to experiment with different styles and moods as the muse takes him. It seems highly likely that there will be Queensryche purists decrying the album, and this track, in particular, but the simple truth of the matter is that Geoff’s moved on from his early days of bombastic, progressive metal and, whilst his musical direction is certainly different, this is skilfully produced and passionately delivered mid-tempo rock raised one step above its competition thanks to its being delivered with great energy and enthusiasm by one of hard rock’s most enduring voices.  ‘The way I roll’ opens with snatches of jazzy saxophone, played by Geoff himself, and a spoken word declaration that this is Geoff circa 2012 before Kelly’s guitar stabs and Gegg’s woozy tempos take the track once again in the direction of Live, recalling that band’s underrated ‘V’ album. The longest track on the album, ‘tomorrow’ marries up syncopated rhythms and a stripped-down approach that gives Geoff’s lyrics and vocals a chance to shine, although it is Kelly who damn near steals the show with a fluid guitar solo set to Eastern-influenced keyboards in the mid-section of the song. Having caught their breath, the band kick back into heavier pastures with the dark-hearted ‘evil’, Kelly employing the full power of the studio to craft a track that feels like a stark message to Geoff’s former band mates as he grinds out the lyric “Why don’t you say it to my face, you don’t move me, you don’t fool me, it doesn’t matter because what you give is what you get…” from between gritted teeth. It’s dark, dramatic, and utterly enthralling.

Moving into the final third of the album, ‘dark money’ moves a distance away from the night-time horrors of ‘evil’ and back towards the pop-infused rock of ‘she slipped away’. Interestingly one influence that unexpectedly raises its head here is David Bowie, with Geoff’s band laying down a heavier version of Bowie’s ‘station to station’-period soundscapes. ‘Those glory days’ has a frighteningly addictive groove to it, the guitars dispatched with a bluesy feel over Gregg’s taut rhythms. Perhaps most unexpected is the synth-led ‘change’ which alters the whole feel of the album, coming on like a spiritual sequel to ‘silent lucidity’, the piano and orchestration giving way to one of Kelly’s best solos on the disc. It’s very different to anything else found here, and possibly the closest in feel to Queensryche even whilst not being in any sense metal. The album concludes with ‘waiting’, another track that slips away from the more contemporary vibe found elsewhere into a more eighties ballad-style that wouldn’t have sounded out of place on ‘Empire’. It seems odd that Geoff would save the two most traditional pieces for last, but with its brave, bluesy fills and funky bass lines underpinning it, it’s far from a simple exercise in nostalgia and one must remember that Geoff has been crafting music in this vein for half his life – old habits, it would seem  die hard.

‘Kings and thieves’ will do nothing to attract those fans who jumped from the Queensryche ship after ‘promised land’, nor, one feels, should it. Geoff is an artist whose integrity has always meant so much more than sales and he has always been explicit about his changing tastes and his desire to move his music in more experimental directions. For those fans who have enjoyed Geoff Tate’s varied output over the years (and there are many) this is Geoff renewing his contract with those faithful, showcasing the fact that he is far from lost without his former band mates. Keeping faith with Kelly Grey was an astute move, Kelly’s production work is second to none, and his guitar work on the album is also exemplary, his bluesy tone the perfect foil for Geoff’s warm, rich voice. Geoff himself, meanwhile, has excelled himself. Where his first solo album felt more like an opportunity to cut loose form the day job, this effort feels like the work of a consummate artist, comfortable with the form and style of his art and confident that this work is his best. Many people will judge this album without hearing a note; many more will write it off for not being heavy enough; but for those who enjoy varied, immaculately played and produced music, ‘Kings and thieves’ is a triumph that allows Geoff the chance to fully shine as the remarkable vocalist that he is. Crafted with the man’s customary lyrical intelligence and with nothing that could be called filler, ‘Kings and thieves’ is a melodic, hard rock triumph and hopefully signals a new fire burning at the heart of a man whose career has already taken more interesting turns than most.

Related posts:



  1. ihatebbq October 17, 2012 1:30 am  Reply

    The last song sounds like something that could have fit on Q2K. The slide guitar is a Kelly Gray trademark from a Q2K b-side called “Howl”, I don’t think its anywhere near reminscent of Empire.

    • phil October 17, 2012 7:54 am  Reply

      Well, obviously we’ll have to agree to differ on that point. ‘Empire’ is, of course, very much a different point in Geoff’s career, but on the other hand I would argue that the stylistic elements – a heavier use of synth, a greater emphasis on ballads than on previous albums – did much to inform Geoff’s latter day career. On the subject of Kelly’s distinctive guitar sound, however, you are absolutely correct – that element of the song is (unsurprisingly) very Q2k but that doesn’t mean the overall feel of the composition is. Thank you, anyway, for your feedback – I suspect this album is liable to be fairly controversial and it’s good to get differing points of view.

  2. Nikki October 20, 2012 12:58 pm  Reply

    “Geoff is an artist whose integrity has always meant so much more than sales”

    Spitting always is a sign of integrity….*NOT* !!!

    • phil October 21, 2012 10:11 am  Reply

      Nikki you have conflated Geoff’s skills as an artist with his personal attributes. Integrity – the act of being true to one’s self – is neither proved nor disproved by an unguarded act of childish frustration, and is anyway unconnected with Geoff’s integrity as a working artist. Geoff the person may be a great philanthropist or a perfect a*****le; I’ve never met the man and am unlikely to; but as an artist he has remained remarkably consistent to his own values. Presumably, as you judge artists by behaviour rather than output, you would rate the Sex pistols (who spat, swore and generally offended everyone in sight), Pink Floyd (Roger spat on a fan, not even his own band mates!) Nirvana (Kurt Cobain regularly spat on cameras, camera men and anyone else in range) and many more such artists as lacking in integrity? I don’t condone Geoff’s behaviour and make no comment upon it in the review – it is immaterial – but if you can’t separate uncivilised behaviour from music then you must have a small record collection indeed.

  3. David October 28, 2012 9:12 pm  Reply

    Unfortunately, Tate for many years has hijacked QR and molded the band (which he was NOT a founding of) according to his own values. That this album sounds like a modern QR album (using the same outside writers he’s used to pass off QR albums) is no coincidence. There is literally no difference. And it would appear that everything his ex bandmates said in their depositions is 100% true. And the marketplace has spoken for years with regard to Tate’s vision. Extremely poor album sales (even for the digital download era) and extremely poor critical reception. In fact, this is one of the first positive reviews i’ve seen. It’s getting skewered pretty much everywhere else.

    I DO take character in account in choosing whom I support with my disposable income, and judging by the response across the net i’m not the only by any means. Geoff Tate’s career is over, as evidenced by his current tour of the dive bar circuit and extremely poor turnout. Tate’s ego and behavior are disgusting and to this day he has not apologized to his ex bandmates for spitting on them repeatedly onstage. The near universal ridicule for him is well deserved.

    • phil October 29, 2012 9:26 am  Reply

      As I’ve already commented on my feelings regarding factoring in an artist’s personality when judging their music, I’ll not resort to repeating myself. However I do find it fascinating that throughout this whole exchange Geoff Tate has been accused of “Hijacking” Queensryche. Did the other members not actually play? Did they all say “no, Geoff, we don’t want to play on ‘Hear in the now frontier'” and then get forced into it? Were they bribed? I mean I understand from the charges (of which I have yet to see any evidence that they are “100% accurate” by the way) that Geoff was potentially violent – are you now saying he battered them into submission on all those albums while they sobbed quietly in the background? How does one man hijack a band exactly? There must have been some level of agreement or those songs simply wouldn’t have been played for so long by that group of musicians.

      Don’t misunderstand me – you’re welcome to your opinion and it’s cool you felt strongly enough to write in – I just fail to understand why everyone has overlooked the simple factor that Geoff Tate simply did not have the power to “hijack” the band. The other members of Queensryche were willing partners up until the point they saw more money elsewhere and thus far it seems that no-one has called them on that.

  4. Glenn December 12, 2012 1:28 am  Reply

    I began listening to Queensryche during the Empire years (as so many others did also) and have followed them since. Subsequent albums were good, but when Q2K came out that pretty much started the decline of Queensryche. Although I did enjoy ‘Tribe’. Operation Mindrcime II was a disaster, American Solider no better and Dedicated to Chaos was just …… it just shouldn’t have been released in my opinion. So, Queensryche parts ways with Tate and he signs with Inside Out and here comes his second solo effort. I’m thinking, maybe he will deliver a solid release. Then again, maybe not. I agree with other reviewers on the web and his choice of Kelly Grey collaborating with him. Not a good choice. Q2K was so rigid, nothing flowed musically, back up vocal harmonies from that album onward were horrendous and this album follows suit. Tate used to have a fantastic voice, but age has shown its colors where he doesn’t have the range anymore. But that doesn’t mean you still can’t put out a quality record. You just need to rethink on how you put the songs together. Each release by Queensryche I would have some hope, but after every listen I questioned myself on why did I ever buy that. And that’s the case with this release. For me, just not a good listen, both musically and lyrically. For others who will enjoy this, good for them if this is their cup of tea. Music is subjective as in you think this is a great album and I’m on the opposite side of the spectrum. If you think of ‘Empire’ and what it was from all aspects; music, lyrics, rockers, ballads this album isn’t even close although it isn’t fair to compare but I just believe Tate could have done so much better in delivering his second solo album. Now I have to just stop myself from purchasing anything else by Geoff Tate. I hate being disappointed time and time again.

    • phil December 12, 2012 12:00 pm  Reply

      A very measured and thoughtful comment – thank you. It’s a shame you don’t like the new disc – we thought it was really good but, as you say, music is a very subjective thing.

  5. Glenn December 13, 2012 12:31 am  Reply

    I will leave it at this. For a man such as Tate and always providing thoughtful and insightful lyrics the verse “she rides me hard like an exercise machine” from the song ‘Say U Luv It’ is downright disgusting and immature. I didn’t know he reverted back to his high school back of the car days. That’s the best he can do at this stage in his life and career? I try not to get caught up in all the drama, but instead will rate an album based on its own merits and sorry to say, this album is sorely lacking any sort of merit. But hey, I’m glad someone likes it, just not me. He has the potential to do so much more and he chose not to. Sad, very sad indeed! Poor sales, poor reviews and poor turnout to his shows will maybe wake him up, but I doubt it. Oh well. Looking forward now to the new Spock’s Beard, Enchant, Riverside and Steve Lukather albums early next year. Cheers!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.